Hi Dima, Here are the things I have at the moment: The IC59 area averaged over angle, my IC79 effective area averaged over angle, and my IC79 effective area in angular bins. For the angle averaged areas the columns are the left edge of the energy bin (minimum energy), and the effective area in square meters for the bin. Note that the IC59 area is averaged over 2*pi of solid angle, while the IC79 is averaged over 2.2*pi. For the angular binned area the columns are the minimum energy of the bin, the minimum cos(zenith) of the bin, and the effective area in meters for the bin. Chris IC59 effective area, averaged over angle: 63.0957 1.48354e-06 79.4328 6.56663e-06 100 5.22774e-05 125.893 0.00020859 158.489 0.00059877 199.526 0.00169794 251.189 0.0037369 316.228 0.00768065 398.107 0.0138057 501.187 0.0243328 630.957 0.0407271 794.328 0.0679595 1000 0.108548 1258.93 0.171739 1584.89 0.271067 1995.26 0.41073 2511.89 0.613012 3162.28 0.899982 3981.07 1.33814 5011.87 1.90653 6309.57 2.64629 7943.28 3.64678 10000 4.97089 12589.3 6.53972 15848.9 8.67284 19952.6 10.9234 25118.9 14.3188 31622.8 17.7744 39810.7 21.7068 50118.7 26.0118 63095.7 32.1777 79432.8 37.7828 100000 45.4003 125893 51.6229 158489 59.8651 199526 67.8313 251189 75.7635 316228 84.535 398107 93.2759 501187 103.761 630957 111.662 794328 122.733 1e+06 130.033 1.25893e+06 138.039 1.58489e+06 155.199 1.99526e+06 155.549 2.51189e+06 163.722 3.16228e+06 179.177 3.98107e+06 181.417 5.01187e+06 186.972 6.30957e+06 194.847 7.94328e+06 208.079 1e+07 202.71 1.25893e+07 217.524 1.58489e+07 225.322 1.99526e+07 217.698 2.51189e+07 222.556 3.16228e+07 234.465 3.98107e+07 232.548 5.01187e+07 240.757 6.30957e+07 258.738 7.94328e+07 250.047 1e+08 256.358 1.25893e+08 254.362 1.58489e+08 268.653 1.99526e+08 269.004 2.51189e+08 259.639 3.16228e+08 252.096 3.98107e+08 250.12 5.01187e+08 282.23 6.30957e+08 236.815 7.94328e+08 291.602 IC79 effective area, averaged over angle: 100 6.24402e-09 125.893 3.5428e-07 158.489 4.62861e-06 199.526 4.39174e-05 251.189 0.000268847 316.228 0.00114214 398.107 0.00333489 501.187 0.00803427 630.957 0.0167707 794.328 0.0318192 1000 0.0591237 1258.93 0.10398 1584.89 0.177643 1995.26 0.293975 2511.89 0.472575 3162.28 0.746427 3981.07 1.14107 5011.87 1.70411 6309.57 2.51033 7943.28 3.62879 10000 5.08626 12589.3 7.05657 15848.9 9.56909 19952.6 12.495 25118.9 16.4303 31622.8 21.2383 39810.7 26.7086 50118.7 32.4495 63095.7 39.9131 79432.8 48.7593 100000 59.328 125893 69.3396 158489 81.6293 199526 93.8036 251189 108.931 316228 122.357 398107 137.705 501187 157.343 630957 178.017 794328 195.311 1e+06 216.249 1.25893e+06 238.256 1.58489e+06 260.36 1.99526e+06 290.456 2.51189e+06 304.427 3.16228e+06 333.441 3.98107e+06 368.008 5.01187e+06 398.404 6.30957e+06 427.55 7.94328e+06 468.837 IC79 effective area, by angle: 100 -1 0 125.893 -1 2.08583e-05 158.489 -1 0.000161369 199.526 -1 0.000991858 251.189 -1 0.00485853 316.228 -1 0.0182761 398.107 -1 0.0505625 501.187 -1 0.11286 630.957 -1 0.223678 794.328 -1 0.41822 1000 -1 0.749098 1258.93 -1 1.30456 1584.89 -1 2.15651 1995.26 -1 3.33911 2511.89 -1 5.34819 3162.28 -1 8.25695 3981.07 -1 11.9912 5011.87 -1 17.038 6309.57 -1 24.5277 7943.28 -1 33.8514 10000 -1 43.5986 12589.3 -1 62.1826 15848.9 -1 76.1583 19952.6 -1 94.7559 25118.9 -1 118.269 31622.8 -1 138.912 39810.7 -1 157.73 50118.7 -1 184.846 63095.7 -1 193.317 79432.8 -1 213.253 100000 -1 231.513 125893 -1 229.811 158489 -1 234.888 199526 -1 227.041 251189 -1 217.397 316228 -1 192.477 398107 -1 193.646 501187 -1 168.898 630957 -1 136.967 794328 -1 106.732 1e+06 -1 105.145 1.25893e+06 -1 83.5279 1.58489e+06 -1 66.3009 1.99526e+06 -1 40.2702 2.51189e+06 -1 32.9158 3.16228e+06 -1 34.4737 3.98107e+06 -1 11.6807 5.01187e+06 -1 19.6979 6.30957e+06 -1 4.21269 7.94328e+06 -1 5.08309 100 -0.9 0 125.893 -0.9 0 158.489 -0.9 9.54387e-06 199.526 -0.9 0.000214176 251.189 -0.9 0.00220727 316.228 -0.9 0.0113872 398.107 -0.9 0.0377528 501.187 -0.9 0.0945756 630.957 -0.9 0.201191 794.328 -0.9 0.367392 1000 -0.9 0.700569 1258.93 -0.9 1.23984 1584.89 -0.9 2.16917 1995.26 -0.9 3.32142 2511.89 -0.9 5.22258 3162.28 -0.9 8.19625 3981.07 -0.9 12.0733 5011.87 -0.9 17.9652 6309.57 -0.9 25.0091 7943.28 -0.9 35.6416 10000 -0.9 50.1619 12589.3 -0.9 64.3293 15848.9 -0.9 82.0568 19952.6 -0.9 108.506 25118.9 -0.9 135.548 31622.8 -0.9 171.057 39810.7 -0.9 203.863 50118.7 -0.9 239.681 63095.7 -0.9 274.901 79432.8 -0.9 316.672 100000 -0.9 367.184 125893 -0.9 398.02 158489 -0.9 421.149 199526 -0.9 396.234 251189 -0.9 465.745 316228 -0.9 450.627 398107 -0.9 458.959 501187 -0.9 416.547 630957 -0.9 359.05 794328 -0.9 433.306 1e+06 -0.9 356.136 1.25893e+06 -0.9 305.62 1.58489e+06 -0.9 346.581 1.99526e+06 -0.9 257.848 2.51189e+06 -0.9 178.748 3.16228e+06 -0.9 143.569 3.98107e+06 -0.9 134.409 5.01187e+06 -0.9 53.8078 6.30957e+06 -0.9 63.3335 7.94328e+06 -0.9 34.0042 100 -0.8 0 125.893 -0.8 0 158.489 -0.8 1.16406e-05 199.526 -0.8 0.000143796 251.189 -0.8 0.0015375 316.228 -0.8 0.00933275 398.107 -0.8 0.0334479 501.187 -0.8 0.089716 630.957 -0.8 0.193203 794.328 -0.8 0.379335 1000 -0.8 0.682653 1258.93 -0.8 1.20308 1584.89 -0.8 1.91079 1995.26 -0.8 3.20753 2511.89 -0.8 5.06221 3162.28 -0.8 7.88618 3981.07 -0.8 12.1981 5011.87 -0.8 17.1499 6309.57 -0.8 25.1084 7943.28 -0.8 33.9569 10000 -0.8 48.0231 12589.3 -0.8 68.9458 15848.9 -0.8 93.7523 19952.6 -0.8 113.57 25118.9 -0.8 147.033 31622.8 -0.8 185.548 39810.7 -0.8 244.905 50118.7 -0.8 263.085 63095.7 -0.8 331.464 79432.8 -0.8 352.462 100000 -0.8 465.669 125893 -0.8 481.042 158489 -0.8 541.596 199526 -0.8 603.696 251189 -0.8 709.329 316228 -0.8 719.295 398107 -0.8 706.848 501187 -0.8 762.859 630957 -0.8 702.943 794328 -0.8 662.623 1e+06 -0.8 673.337 1.25893e+06 -0.8 640.95 1.58489e+06 -0.8 587.118 1.99526e+06 -0.8 453.343 2.51189e+06 -0.8 397.795 3.16228e+06 -0.8 354.582 3.98107e+06 -0.8 339.26 5.01187e+06 -0.8 236.882 6.30957e+06 -0.8 210.019 7.94328e+06 -0.8 151.826 100 -0.7 0 125.893 -0.7 0 158.489 -0.7 1.05411e-05 199.526 -0.7 0.000171327 251.189 -0.7 0.00132877 316.228 -0.7 0.00864067 398.107 -0.7 0.0297228 501.187 -0.7 0.0756995 630.957 -0.7 0.176006 794.328 -0.7 0.322009 1000 -0.7 0.610231 1258.93 -0.7 1.07218 1584.89 -0.7 1.8545 1995.26 -0.7 3.1328 2511.89 -0.7 4.9394 3162.28 -0.7 7.82789 3981.07 -0.7 11.5093 5011.87 -0.7 17.6856 6309.57 -0.7 24.7291 7943.28 -0.7 36.9954 10000 -0.7 49.8571 12589.3 -0.7 70.3913 15848.9 -0.7 95.2616 19952.6 -0.7 120.299 25118.9 -0.7 152.817 31622.8 -0.7 199.051 39810.7 -0.7 256.936 50118.7 -0.7 289.29 63095.7 -0.7 360.764 79432.8 -0.7 430.407 100000 -0.7 487.412 125893 -0.7 564.129 158489 -0.7 635.309 199526 -0.7 697.324 251189 -0.7 840.58 316228 -0.7 847.853 398107 -0.7 848.9 501187 -0.7 913.87 630957 -0.7 1021.28 794328 -0.7 853.734 1e+06 -0.7 937.869 1.25893e+06 -0.7 905.317 1.58489e+06 -0.7 946.486 1.99526e+06 -0.7 984.701 2.51189e+06 -0.7 748.495 3.16228e+06 -0.7 644.936 3.98107e+06 -0.7 558.289 5.01187e+06 -0.7 542.948 6.30957e+06 -0.7 335.667 7.94328e+06 -0.7 349.789 100 -0.6 0 125.893 -0.6 9.33043e-07 158.489 -0.6 3.14677e-05 199.526 -0.6 0.000194841 251.189 -0.6 0.00150325 316.228 -0.6 0.00738074 398.107 -0.6 0.0275717 501.187 -0.6 0.0743228 630.957 -0.6 0.155848 794.328 -0.6 0.306327 1000 -0.6 0.592608 1258.93 -0.6 1.01783 1584.89 -0.6 1.80967 1995.26 -0.6 3.02805 2511.89 -0.6 4.86644 3162.28 -0.6 7.7273 3981.07 -0.6 11.9066 5011.87 -0.6 17.9709 6309.57 -0.6 26.5326 7943.28 -0.6 38.7793 10000 -0.6 52.1613 12589.3 -0.6 73.3264 15848.9 -0.6 98.4809 19952.6 -0.6 126.969 25118.9 -0.6 168.792 31622.8 -0.6 212.48 39810.7 -0.6 251.143 50118.7 -0.6 311.896 63095.7 -0.6 376.766 79432.8 -0.6 482.069 100000 -0.6 556.639 125893 -0.6 637.905 158489 -0.6 773.878 199526 -0.6 868.999 251189 -0.6 928.671 316228 -0.6 1005.57 398107 -0.6 1061.34 501187 -0.6 1235.63 630957 -0.6 1233.64 794328 -0.6 1348.22 1e+06 -0.6 1272.22 1.25893e+06 -0.6 1337.54 1.58489e+06 -0.6 1256.46 1.99526e+06 -0.6 1325.92 2.51189e+06 -0.6 1198.81 3.16228e+06 -0.6 1033.44 3.98107e+06 -0.6 1135.05 5.01187e+06 -0.6 1059.09 6.30957e+06 -0.6 672.692 7.94328e+06 -0.6 539.192 100 -0.5 0 125.893 -0.5 2.68212e-06 158.489 -0.5 3.14122e-05 199.526 -0.5 0.000358487 251.189 -0.5 0.00227707 316.228 -0.5 0.00967283 398.107 -0.5 0.0284125 501.187 -0.5 0.0703583 630.957 -0.5 0.153574 794.328 -0.5 0.297774 1000 -0.5 0.562638 1258.93 -0.5 1.00796 1584.89 -0.5 1.77596 1995.26 -0.5 3.00028 2511.89 -0.5 4.80369 3162.28 -0.5 7.8254 3981.07 -0.5 12.3099 5011.87 -0.5 17.9469 6309.57 -0.5 26.2744 7943.28 -0.5 39.5977 10000 -0.5 55.282 12589.3 -0.5 75.5798 15848.9 -0.5 103.296 19952.6 -0.5 133.077 25118.9 -0.5 170.535 31622.8 -0.5 232.213 39810.7 -0.5 290.623 50118.7 -0.5 343.764 63095.7 -0.5 439.312 79432.8 -0.5 533.193 100000 -0.5 619.512 125893 -0.5 762.793 158489 -0.5 843.826 199526 -0.5 1003.71 251189 -0.5 1140.71 316228 -0.5 1191.81 398107 -0.5 1357.84 501187 -0.5 1495.7 630957 -0.5 1698.04 794328 -0.5 1849.08 1e+06 -0.5 1942.36 1.25893e+06 -0.5 1913.33 1.58489e+06 -0.5 2046.04 1.99526e+06 -0.5 1847.14 2.51189e+06 -0.5 1845.08 3.16228e+06 -0.5 1768.28 3.98107e+06 -0.5 1734.71 5.01187e+06 -0.5 1768.16 6.30957e+06 -0.5 1769.11 7.94328e+06 -0.5 1554.9 100 -0.4 0 125.893 -0.4 2.61386e-06 158.489 -0.4 4.72538e-05 199.526 -0.4 0.000552855 251.189 -0.4 0.00298876 316.228 -0.4 0.0131217 398.107 -0.4 0.0329437 501.187 -0.4 0.0790846 630.957 -0.4 0.157312 794.328 -0.4 0.313374 1000 -0.4 0.5698 1258.93 -0.4 1.00592 1584.89 -0.4 1.77807 1995.26 -0.4 2.96102 2511.89 -0.4 4.96666 3162.28 -0.4 7.69129 3981.07 -0.4 12.4769 5011.87 -0.4 18.0066 6309.57 -0.4 28.183 7943.28 -0.4 39.3439 10000 -0.4 55.9175 12589.3 -0.4 77.6185 15848.9 -0.4 107.158 19952.6 -0.4 139.473 25118.9 -0.4 185.287 31622.8 -0.4 245.499 39810.7 -0.4 290.88 50118.7 -0.4 390.261 63095.7 -0.4 455.625 79432.8 -0.4 573.549 100000 -0.4 679.334 125893 -0.4 847.489 158489 -0.4 1013.95 199526 -0.4 1106.69 251189 -0.4 1309.19 316228 -0.4 1535.49 398107 -0.4 1687.51 501187 -0.4 1849.86 630957 -0.4 2132.01 794328 -0.4 2386.57 1e+06 -0.4 2543.16 1.25893e+06 -0.4 2618.33 1.58489e+06 -0.4 2918.68 1.99526e+06 -0.4 2852.73 2.51189e+06 -0.4 3056.46 3.16228e+06 -0.4 3234.23 3.98107e+06 -0.4 3234.23 5.01187e+06 -0.4 3302.5 6.30957e+06 -0.4 2987.62 7.94328e+06 -0.4 3147.05 100 -0.3 0 125.893 -0.3 1.22669e-06 158.489 -0.3 4.98954e-05 199.526 -0.3 0.000565289 251.189 -0.3 0.00402733 316.228 -0.3 0.0149901 398.107 -0.3 0.0386894 501.187 -0.3 0.0877812 630.957 -0.3 0.175054 794.328 -0.3 0.330386 1000 -0.3 0.610307 1258.93 -0.3 1.05011 1584.89 -0.3 1.833 1995.26 -0.3 3.09124 2511.89 -0.3 4.89618 3162.28 -0.3 7.71326 3981.07 -0.3 11.9684 5011.87 -0.3 18.5322 6309.57 -0.3 28.4912 7943.28 -0.3 41.9193 10000 -0.3 58.7309 12589.3 -0.3 82.3371 15848.9 -0.3 115.443 19952.6 -0.3 153.96 25118.9 -0.3 198.746 31622.8 -0.3 253.909 39810.7 -0.3 326.617 50118.7 -0.3 391.52 63095.7 -0.3 517.96 79432.8 -0.3 630.154 100000 -0.3 763.503 125893 -0.3 923.071 158489 -0.3 1102.01 199526 -0.3 1276.13 251189 -0.3 1415.83 316228 -0.3 1743.61 398107 -0.3 1879.09 501187 -0.3 2277.97 630957 -0.3 2605.69 794328 -0.3 2732.48 1e+06 -0.3 3165.56 1.25893e+06 -0.3 3563.85 1.58489e+06 -0.3 3784.39 1.99526e+06 -0.3 4174.81 2.51189e+06 -0.3 4147.72 3.16228e+06 -0.3 4653.95 3.98107e+06 -0.3 5013.94 5.01187e+06 -0.3 4927.26 6.30957e+06 -0.3 5267.57 7.94328e+06 -0.3 5889.8 100 -0.2 6.78823e-07 125.893 -0.2 5.71933e-06 158.489 -0.2 7.669e-05 199.526 -0.2 0.000805706 251.189 -0.2 0.00446954 316.228 -0.2 0.0160531 398.107 -0.2 0.0410471 501.187 -0.2 0.0941152 630.957 -0.2 0.185562 794.328 -0.2 0.351062 1000 -0.2 0.62797 1258.93 -0.2 1.12505 1584.89 -0.2 1.85696 1995.26 -0.2 3.17506 2511.89 -0.2 5.13824 3162.28 -0.2 8.12898 3981.07 -0.2 12.6041 5011.87 -0.2 19.014 6309.57 -0.2 27.9434 7943.28 -0.2 41.4885 10000 -0.2 60.1807 12589.3 -0.2 82.1896 15848.9 -0.2 113.665 19952.6 -0.2 151.441 25118.9 -0.2 211.241 31622.8 -0.2 271.198 39810.7 -0.2 347.728 50118.7 -0.2 435.141 63095.7 -0.2 546.842 79432.8 -0.2 676.839 100000 -0.2 862.274 125893 -0.2 1047.13 158489 -0.2 1223.19 199526 -0.2 1447.1 251189 -0.2 1774.84 316228 -0.2 1888.2 398107 -0.2 2383.09 501187 -0.2 2741.22 630957 -0.2 3087.25 794328 -0.2 3492.16 1e+06 -0.2 4120.01 1.25893e+06 -0.2 4341.2 1.58489e+06 -0.2 4788.77 1.99526e+06 -0.2 5699.27 2.51189e+06 -0.2 5952.9 3.16228e+06 -0.2 6861.27 3.98107e+06 -0.2 7360.6 5.01187e+06 -0.2 8224.46 6.30957e+06 -0.2 8628.03 7.94328e+06 -0.2 9470.47 100 -0.1 0 125.893 -0.1 4.48246e-06 158.489 -0.1 7.11516e-05 199.526 -0.1 0.000681166 251.189 -0.1 0.00372927 316.228 -0.1 0.0138032 398.107 -0.1 0.0382274 501.187 -0.1 0.0852217 630.957 -0.1 0.177026 794.328 -0.1 0.326028 1000 -0.1 0.628248 1258.93 -0.1 1.11106 1584.89 -0.1 1.8665 1995.26 -0.1 3.16758 2511.89 -0.1 5.13503 3162.28 -0.1 8.21254 3981.07 -0.1 12.1774 5011.87 -0.1 19.1963 6309.57 -0.1 28.981 7943.28 -0.1 41.7185 10000 -0.1 60.9401 12589.3 -0.1 84.0684 15848.9 -0.1 114.63 19952.6 -0.1 156.812 25118.9 -0.1 215.232 31622.8 -0.1 280.695 39810.7 -0.1 368.324 50118.7 -0.1 468.747 63095.7 -0.1 579.463 79432.8 -0.1 726.172 100000 -0.1 925.831 125893 -0.1 1068.49 158489 -0.1 1342.55 199526 -0.1 1615.16 251189 -0.1 1892.67 316228 -0.1 2358.8 398107 -0.1 2816.41 501187 -0.1 3201.31 630957 -0.1 3824.51 794328 -0.1 4514.27 1e+06 -0.1 5170.48 1.25893e+06 -0.1 6127.93 1.58489e+06 -0.1 6900.17 1.99526e+06 -0.1 8140.53 2.51189e+06 -0.1 9104.34 3.16228e+06 -0.1 10475.2 3.98107e+06 -0.1 11669 5.01187e+06 -0.1 13278 6.30957e+06 -0.1 14818.1 7.94328e+06 -0.1 16762.2 100 0 0 125.893 0 0 158.489 0 2.23672e-06 199.526 0 9.50026e-05 251.189 0 0.000300597 316.228 0 0.00151005 398.107 0 0.0041767 501.187 0 0.00971541 630.957 0 0.02478 794.328 0 0.0473333 1000 0 0.0935415 1258.93 0 0.16663 1584.89 0 0.301402 1995.26 0 0.535539 2511.89 0 0.997654 3162.28 0 1.68216 3981.07 0 2.83724 5011.87 0 4.75768 6309.57 0 7.13156 7943.28 0 11.2135 10000 0 18.1026 12589.3 0 26.1901 15848.9 0 40.4073 19952.6 0 59.5376 25118.9 0 82.7269 31622.8 0 118.37 39810.7 0 164.893 50118.7 0 209.534 63095.7 0 262.767 79432.8 0 366.13 100000 0 491.009 125893 0 578.412 158489 0 742.033 199526 0 955.825 251189 0 1147.54 316228 0 1368.36 398107 0 1577.07 501187 0 2041.79 630957 0 2551.85 794328 0 2854.19 1e+06 0 3223.34 1.25893e+06 0 4064.49 1.58489e+06 0 4664.22 1.99526e+06 0 5800.52 2.51189e+06 0 6432.7 3.16228e+06 0 7046.25 3.98107e+06 0 8816.98 5.01187e+06 0 9899.91 6.30957e+06 0 11725 7.94328e+06 0 13065.6 On Apr 21, 2015, at 4:23 PM, Dmitry Chirkin wrote: Hi Chris, could you send me effective area for your analysis (area vs. energy, optionally binned in zenith bands). You had done some comparisons with other analyses, so you must have their effective areas too? Could you send me those as well? I am updating the effective area plot that shows areas from IceCube and extensions for main analyses branches. Thank you! Dima