General/common comments from all reviewers
1) There are many pieces that will not be understandable to an outside reader, either because the explanation is insufficient, or because there is too much IceCube jargon. The figures also need work, so that the axis labels are all clear and well explained, and the figures are large enough to see.

2) One example of this is the regularization procedure, which is not very clear. One particular issue concerns the tradeoffs between resolution (in z), and the degree of regularization. Do we really have 10 m resolution in z (as is implied by the 10 m bins)?

3) The paper needs to discuss the differences in approach and in results between the current analysis and the previous ice-model paper. The differences between the two models seem larger than the estimated systematic errors in the two methods. This implies that the systematic errors for at least one of the two papers are underestimated, or some systematic difference is not included. This needs to be discussed; we cannot just ignore the differences from a paper that most of us (you included) signed.

Comments from Dawn:
line 2 - is "currently under construction" still being used, now that IceCube is complete, or do we officially say it's complete only when IC86 is online? line 4 - "helping to elucidate" should be "in order to elucidate" or simply "to elucidate". lines 5-7: The sentence "Icecube uses...." should be tightened up, without using the phrase "for example". The phrase "cosmic neutrinos" isn't necessary since we see atmospheric neutrinos the same way as astrophysical neutrinos. line 9 - Is the introductory paragraph the right place for a technical description of the DOMs? Also, DOMs are defined both on line 9-10 and on line 41, and different capitalization for the full phrase "digital optical modules" is used on the different lines. I think the definition of DOMs should be moved to a Detector Description section before, or at the beginning of, the Flasher dataset description. lines 13-20: Detector geometry should be included in the Detector description section. line 13: the number 17 is at the end of the line and the unit of m is on the next line. If using TeX or LaTeX, use a tilde ~ between all numbers and units to ensure they are on the same line. line 21: "propagation in transparent medium" should be "propagation in a transparent medium" line 33: the contents of section 3 should not be in a paranthetical statement. line 33: "The likelihood function" is the first mention of the likelihood function, so it should briefly say what the likelihood function does, i.e. is it the likelihood of the scattering and absorption parameters, or ...? line 41: as aforementioned, this is the second definition of DOMs. This is where the Detector Description/technical info from line 9 and following should be. line 42: The flasher board should be included in the technical description of the DOMs. Also, the flasher wavelength of 405 nm should be mentioned here, not left until a paranthetical statement in line 79, as it currently is. Figure 1: The strings should be denoted with shapes as well as colors. In the caption, "IceCube parts added in the following years" should be "IceCube deployment locations in the following years", or something like that. Figure 1: On the right hand side, there should be an explanation of what the colors/sizes of the hits in the flasher events means. Line 51: I found it a little confusing to say "the variation" in figure 3 is due to relative light yield etc., when the overall variation is due to ice properties (i.e. the dust layer is easily visible). Maybe say the "dom-to-dom" variation or variation between neighboring DOMs is due to the light yield factors etc., as distinct from the overall variation. Line 51: I don't think the phrase "due to" needs to be repeated. line 58: first mention of ATWD with no explanation of what it stands for. This should be in the Detector Description/technical description of the DOMs. line 61: "saturated DOMs" should be clarified... it is the PMTs that are saturated. line 69: AMANDA was not defined; it should be mentioned perhaps on line 29 with respect to reference 3. line 79-80: maybe it should be mentioned here that future IceCube flashers will have LEDs with wavelengths other than 405 nm, rather than waiting to line 290. line 85: a GPU is mentioned further on in the text on line 169, so the GPU should be mentioned here instead of "special purpose hardware". Figure 5: the reference to a "bare muon" seems stranded, since bare muons are not mentioned until later on in the text. line 105: I would put the expression for the linear combination of of the two functions HG and SL AFTER the definition of the two functions. line 115: the definition of g=<cos theta> should be moved earlier, near line 106. figure 7: what is f_SAM? The text refers to f_SL. lines 120-123: I don't think all the parantheses are necessary. line 146 and 149: I'm confused by what is meant by "unwanted fluctuations", and by this section on "regularizatrion terms" generally. In line 147, second derivatives of what? line 169: as aforementioned, the GPU should be mentioned before when PPC is first mentioned. line 180: why is chi_q used for the total charge while chi_t is used for the charge split into 25 ns bins? Is this chi the same as the likelihood function in section 5? line 242: agreement between simulated and reconstructed ice properties is strong, but as I understand section 7, the ice properties were derived by minimizing the difference between simulation and data. So is this a sanity check or a stronger statement? figure 14: the statistics for the 4 "AHA" plots in the lower right look worse than the SPICE plots above. This whole figure is a little hard to follow; AHA plots should be labeled as such and SPICE plots likewise so one doesn't have to keep looking at the caption.